# DExTer : Debugging Experience Tester # ~~~~~~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ # # Part of the LLVM Project, under the Apache License v2.0 with LLVM Exceptions. # See https://llvm.org/LICENSE.txt for license information. # SPDX-License-Identifier: Apache-2.0 WITH LLVM-exception """Calculate a 'score' based on some dextIR. Assign penalties based on different commands to decrease the score. 1.000 would be a perfect score. 0.000 is the worst theoretical score possible. """ from collections import defaultdict, namedtuple, Counter import difflib import os from itertools import groupby from dex.command.StepValueInfo import StepValueInfo from dex.command.commands.DexExpectWatchBase import format_address PenaltyCommand = namedtuple("PenaltyCommand", ["pen_dict", "max_penalty"]) # 'meta' field used in different ways by different things PenaltyInstance = namedtuple("PenaltyInstance", ["meta", "the_penalty"]) def add_heuristic_tool_arguments(parser): parser.add_argument( "--penalty-variable-optimized", type=int, default=3, help="set the penalty multiplier for each" " occurrence of a variable that was optimized" " away", metavar="", ) parser.add_argument( "--penalty-misordered-values", type=int, default=3, help="set the penalty multiplier for each" " occurrence of a misordered value.", metavar="", ) parser.add_argument( "--penalty-irretrievable", type=int, default=4, help="set the penalty multiplier for each" " occurrence of a variable that couldn't" " be retrieved", metavar="", ) parser.add_argument( "--penalty-not-evaluatable", type=int, default=5, help="set the penalty multiplier for each" " occurrence of a variable that couldn't" " be evaluated", metavar="", ) parser.add_argument( "--penalty-missing-values", type=int, default=6, help="set the penalty multiplier for each missing" " value", metavar="", ) parser.add_argument( "--penalty-incorrect-values", type=int, default=7, help="set the penalty multiplier for each" " occurrence of an unexpected value.", metavar="", ) parser.add_argument( "--penalty-unreachable", type=int, default=4, # XXX XXX XXX selected by random help="set the penalty for each line stepped onto that should" " have been unreachable.", metavar="", ) parser.add_argument( "--penalty-misordered-steps", type=int, default=2, # XXX XXX XXX selected by random help="set the penalty for differences in the order of steps" " the program was expected to observe.", metavar="", ) parser.add_argument( "--penalty-missing-step", type=int, default=4, # XXX XXX XXX selected by random help="set the penalty for the program skipping over a step.", metavar="", ) parser.add_argument( "--penalty-incorrect-program-state", type=int, default=4, # XXX XXX XXX selected by random help="set the penalty for the program never entering an expected state" " or entering an unexpected state.", metavar="", ) class PenaltyLineRanges: def __init__(self, first_step, penalty): self.ranges = [(first_step, first_step)] self.penalty = penalty def add_step(self, next_step, penalty): last_range = self.ranges[-1] last_step = last_range[1] if next_step == last_step + 1: self.ranges[-1] = (last_range[0], next_step) else: self.ranges.append((next_step, next_step)) self.penalty += penalty def __str__(self): range_to_str = lambda r: str(r[0]) if r[0] == r[1] else f"{r[0]}-{r[1]}" if self.ranges[0][0] == self.ranges[-1][1]: text = f"step {self.ranges[0][0]}" else: step_list = ", ".join([range_to_str(r) for r in self.ranges]) text = f"steps [{step_list}]" if self.penalty: text += " [-{}]".format(self.penalty) return text class Heuristic(object): def __init__(self, context, steps): self.context = context self.penalties = {} self.address_resolutions = {} worst_penalty = max( [ self.penalty_variable_optimized, self.penalty_irretrievable, self.penalty_not_evaluatable, self.penalty_incorrect_values, self.penalty_missing_values, self.penalty_unreachable, self.penalty_missing_step, self.penalty_misordered_steps, ] ) # Before evaluating scoring commands, evaluate address values. try: for command in steps.commands["DexDeclareAddress"]: command.address_resolutions = self.address_resolutions command.eval(steps) except KeyError: pass # Get DexExpectWatchType results. try: for command in steps.commands["DexExpectWatchType"]: command.eval(steps) maximum_possible_penalty = min(3, len(command.values)) * worst_penalty name, p = self._calculate_expect_watch_penalties( command, maximum_possible_penalty ) name = name + " ExpectType" self.penalties[name] = PenaltyCommand(p, maximum_possible_penalty) except KeyError: pass # Get DexExpectWatchValue results. try: for command in steps.commands["DexExpectWatchValue"]: command.address_resolutions = self.address_resolutions command.eval(steps) maximum_possible_penalty = min(3, len(command.values)) * worst_penalty name, p = self._calculate_expect_watch_penalties( command, maximum_possible_penalty ) name = name + " ExpectValue" self.penalties[name] = PenaltyCommand(p, maximum_possible_penalty) except KeyError: pass try: penalties = defaultdict(list) maximum_possible_penalty_all = 0 for expect_state in steps.commands["DexExpectProgramState"]: success = expect_state.eval(steps) p = 0 if success else self.penalty_incorrect_program_state meta = "expected {}: {}".format( "{} times".format(expect_state.times) if expect_state.times >= 0 else "at least once", expect_state.program_state_text, ) if success: meta = "{}".format(meta) maximum_possible_penalty = self.penalty_incorrect_program_state maximum_possible_penalty_all += maximum_possible_penalty name = expect_state.program_state_text penalties[meta] = [ PenaltyInstance("{} times".format(len(expect_state.encounters)), p) ] self.penalties["expected program states"] = PenaltyCommand( penalties, maximum_possible_penalty_all ) except KeyError: pass # Get the total number of each step kind. step_kind_counts = defaultdict(int) for step in getattr(steps, "steps"): step_kind_counts[step.step_kind] += 1 # Get DexExpectStepKind results. penalties = defaultdict(list) maximum_possible_penalty_all = 0 try: for command in steps.commands["DexExpectStepKind"]: command.eval() # Cap the penalty at 2 * expected count or else 1 maximum_possible_penalty = max(command.count * 2, 1) p = abs(command.count - step_kind_counts[command.name]) actual_penalty = min(p, maximum_possible_penalty) key = ( "{}".format(command.name) if actual_penalty else "{}".format(command.name) ) penalties[key] = [PenaltyInstance(p, actual_penalty)] maximum_possible_penalty_all += maximum_possible_penalty self.penalties["step kind differences"] = PenaltyCommand( penalties, maximum_possible_penalty_all ) except KeyError: pass if "DexUnreachable" in steps.commands: cmds = steps.commands["DexUnreachable"] unreach_count = 0 # Find steps with unreachable in them ureachs = [s for s in steps.steps if "DexUnreachable" in s.watches.keys()] # There's no need to match up cmds with the actual watches upen = self.penalty_unreachable count = upen * len(ureachs) if count != 0: d = dict() for x in ureachs: msg = "line {} reached".format(x.current_location.lineno) d[msg] = [PenaltyInstance(upen, upen)] else: d = {"No unreachable lines seen": [PenaltyInstance(0, 0)]} total = PenaltyCommand(d, len(cmds) * upen) self.penalties["unreachable lines"] = total if "DexExpectStepOrder" in steps.commands: cmds = steps.commands["DexExpectStepOrder"] # Form a list of which line/cmd we _should_ have seen cmd_num_lst = [(x, c.get_line()) for c in cmds for x in c.sequence] # Order them by the sequence number cmd_num_lst.sort(key=lambda t: t[0]) # Strip out sequence key cmd_num_lst = [y for x, y in cmd_num_lst] # Now do the same, but for the actually observed lines/cmds ss = steps.steps deso = [s for s in ss if "DexExpectStepOrder" in s.watches.keys()] deso = [s.watches["DexExpectStepOrder"] for s in deso] # We rely on the steps remaining in order here order_list = [int(x.expression) for x in deso] # First off, check to see whether or not there are missing items expected = Counter(cmd_num_lst) seen = Counter(order_list) unseen_line_dict = dict() skipped_line_dict = dict() mispen = self.penalty_missing_step num_missing = 0 num_repeats = 0 for k, v in expected.items(): if k not in seen: msg = "Line {} not seen".format(k) unseen_line_dict[msg] = [PenaltyInstance(mispen, mispen)] num_missing += v elif v > seen[k]: msg = "Line {} skipped at least once".format(k) skipped_line_dict[msg] = [PenaltyInstance(mispen, mispen)] num_missing += v - seen[k] elif v < seen[k]: # Don't penalise unexpected extra sightings of a line # for now num_repeats = seen[k] - v pass if len(unseen_line_dict) == 0: pi = PenaltyInstance(0, 0) unseen_line_dict["All lines were seen"] = [pi] if len(skipped_line_dict) == 0: pi = PenaltyInstance(0, 0) skipped_line_dict["No lines were skipped"] = [pi] total = PenaltyCommand(unseen_line_dict, len(expected) * mispen) self.penalties["Unseen lines"] = total total = PenaltyCommand(skipped_line_dict, len(expected) * mispen) self.penalties["Skipped lines"] = total ordpen = self.penalty_misordered_steps cmd_num_lst = [str(x) for x in cmd_num_lst] order_list = [str(x) for x in order_list] lst = list(difflib.Differ().compare(cmd_num_lst, order_list)) diff_detail = Counter(l[0] for l in lst) assert "?" not in diff_detail # Diffs are hard to interpret; there are many algorithms for # condensing them. Ignore all that, and just print out the changed # sequences, it's up to the user to interpret what's going on. def filt_lines(s, seg, e, key): lst = [s] for x in seg: if x[0] == key: lst.append(int(x[2:])) lst.append(e) return lst diff_msgs = dict() def reportdiff(start_idx, segment, end_idx): msg = "Order mismatch, expected linenos {}, saw {}" expected_linenos = filt_lines(start_idx, segment, end_idx, "-") seen_linenos = filt_lines(start_idx, segment, end_idx, "+") msg = msg.format(expected_linenos, seen_linenos) diff_msgs[msg] = [PenaltyInstance(ordpen, ordpen)] # Group by changed segments. start_expt_step = 0 end_expt_step = 0 to_print_lst = [] for k, subit in groupby(lst, lambda x: x[0] == " "): if k: # Whitespace group nochanged = [x for x in subit] end_expt_step = int(nochanged[0][2:]) if len(to_print_lst) > 0: reportdiff(start_expt_step, to_print_lst, end_expt_step) start_expt_step = int(nochanged[-1][2:]) to_print_lst = [] else: # Diff group, save for printing to_print_lst = [x for x in subit] # If there was a dangling different step, print that too. if len(to_print_lst) > 0: reportdiff(start_expt_step, to_print_lst, "[End]") if len(diff_msgs) == 0: diff_msgs["No lines misordered"] = [PenaltyInstance(0, 0)] total = PenaltyCommand(diff_msgs, len(cmd_num_lst) * ordpen) self.penalties["Misordered lines"] = total return def _calculate_expect_watch_penalties(self, c, maximum_possible_penalty): penalties = defaultdict(list) if c.line_range[0] == c.line_range[-1]: line_range = str(c.line_range[0]) else: line_range = "{}-{}".format(c.line_range[0], c.line_range[-1]) name = "{}:{} [{}]".format(os.path.basename(c.path), line_range, c.expression) num_actual_watches = len(c.expected_watches) + len(c.unexpected_watches) penalty_available = maximum_possible_penalty # Only penalize for missing values if we have actually seen a watch # that's returned us an actual value at some point, or if we've not # encountered the value at all. if num_actual_watches or c.times_encountered == 0: for v in c.missing_values: current_penalty = min(penalty_available, self.penalty_missing_values) penalty_available -= current_penalty penalties["missing values"].append(PenaltyInstance(v, current_penalty)) for v in c.encountered_values: penalties["expected encountered watches"].append( PenaltyInstance(v, 0) ) penalty_descriptions = [ (self.penalty_not_evaluatable, c.invalid_watches, "could not evaluate"), ( self.penalty_variable_optimized, c.optimized_out_watches, "result optimized away", ), (self.penalty_misordered_values, c.misordered_watches, "misordered result"), ( self.penalty_irretrievable, c.irretrievable_watches, "result could not be retrieved", ), (self.penalty_incorrect_values, c.unexpected_watches, "unexpected result"), ] for penalty_score, watches, description in penalty_descriptions: # We only penalize the encountered issue for each missing value per # command but we still want to record each one, so set the penalty # to 0 after the threshold is passed. times_to_penalize = len(c.missing_values) for w in watches: times_to_penalize -= 1 penalty_score = min(penalty_available, penalty_score) penalty_available -= penalty_score penalties[description].append(PenaltyInstance(w, penalty_score)) if not times_to_penalize: penalty_score = 0 return name, penalties @property def penalty(self): result = 0 maximum_allowed_penalty = 0 for name, pen_cmd in self.penalties.items(): maximum_allowed_penalty += pen_cmd.max_penalty value = pen_cmd.pen_dict for category, inst_list in value.items(): result += sum(x.the_penalty for x in inst_list) return min(result, maximum_allowed_penalty) @property def max_penalty(self): return sum(p_cat.max_penalty for p_cat in self.penalties.values()) @property def score(self): try: return 1.0 - (self.penalty / float(self.max_penalty)) except ZeroDivisionError: return float("nan") @property def summary_string(self): score = self.score isnan = score != score # pylint: disable=comparison-with-itself color = "g" if score < 0.25 or isnan: color = "r" elif score < 0.75: color = "y" return "<{}>({:.4f})".format(color, score) @property def verbose_output(self): # noqa string = "" # Add address resolutions if present. if self.address_resolutions: if self.resolved_addresses: string += "\nResolved Addresses:\n" for addr, res in self.resolved_addresses.items(): string += f" '{addr}': {res}\n" if self.unresolved_addresses: string += "\n" string += f"Unresolved Addresses:\n {self.unresolved_addresses}\n" string += "\n" for command in sorted(self.penalties): pen_cmd = self.penalties[command] maximum_possible_penalty = pen_cmd.max_penalty total_penalty = 0 lines = [] for category in sorted(pen_cmd.pen_dict): lines.append(" {}:\n".format(category)) step_value_results = {} for result, penalty in pen_cmd.pen_dict[category]: if not isinstance(result, StepValueInfo): continue if result.expected_value not in step_value_results: step_value_results[result.expected_value] = PenaltyLineRanges( result.step_index, penalty ) else: step_value_results[result.expected_value].add_step( result.step_index, penalty ) for value, penalty_line_range in step_value_results.items(): text = f"({value}): {penalty_line_range}" total_penalty += penalty_line_range.penalty lines.append(" {}\n".format(text)) for result, penalty in pen_cmd.pen_dict[category]: if isinstance(result, StepValueInfo): continue else: text = str(result) if penalty: assert penalty > 0, penalty total_penalty += penalty text += " [-{}]".format(penalty) lines.append(" {}\n".format(text)) lines.append("\n") string += " {} [{}/{}]\n".format( command, total_penalty, maximum_possible_penalty ) for line in lines: string += line string += "\n" return string @property def resolved_addresses(self): return { addr: format_address(res) for addr, res in self.address_resolutions.items() if res is not None } @property def unresolved_addresses(self): return [addr for addr, res in self.address_resolutions.items() if res is None] @property def penalty_variable_optimized(self): return self.context.options.penalty_variable_optimized @property def penalty_irretrievable(self): return self.context.options.penalty_irretrievable @property def penalty_not_evaluatable(self): return self.context.options.penalty_not_evaluatable @property def penalty_incorrect_values(self): return self.context.options.penalty_incorrect_values @property def penalty_missing_values(self): return self.context.options.penalty_missing_values @property def penalty_misordered_values(self): return self.context.options.penalty_misordered_values @property def penalty_unreachable(self): return self.context.options.penalty_unreachable @property def penalty_missing_step(self): return self.context.options.penalty_missing_step @property def penalty_misordered_steps(self): return self.context.options.penalty_misordered_steps @property def penalty_incorrect_program_state(self): return self.context.options.penalty_incorrect_program_state